Feedback

Thread #827097

Not synched.


Bottom Identity
Search [iqdb] (799 KB, 786x576, tumblr_nlextc1Lee1tanofjo1_1280.png)
Hightmare
Hey, people. I've been pondering a project.
I'd like to collaborate on a language with some people.
Unfortunately, most glossopoeists are inflexible in their tastes, so it is best to gain traction outside the hobby-sphere.
Would any of you be interested?
Search [iqdb] (111 KB, 682x935, Albrecht_Dürer_-_The_Little_Ow(…).jpg)
Is there somewhere to follow along with the collaboration and process?
I've seen some similar projects come and go
i could keep an eye on it but i can't promise any commitment
Anno
>>827097 (OP)
cool picture
Anno
>>827291
We could just do it here. It would be open to whomever wanted to contribute and wouldn't require an account unlike Discord.
>>827354
this site probably isn't the best place to coordinate long-term projects and catalog progress
do you have a group of people or any rough plans?
Anno
>>827367
I was hoping you all would be that grouo of people.
Search [iqdb] (75 KB, 1280x720, [HorribleSubs] Dororo - 19 [72(…).jpg)
You might be disappointed here. There aren't many people browsing here. I don't think they'd find it too interesting
I've never had a desire to construct a language, but i am interested in natural language so there's some overlap.

do you have some foundation to go off of?
have you seen bibliaridion's dos & donts?
>>>/watch?v=bjDqBz7kw1M
>>>/watch?v=FHK1gO2Mh68
the second link is a whole playlist
Anno
Working on a conlang sounds interesting, there's definitely a lot of rough edges around existing conlangs
Anno
>>827596
Do tell.
Anno
>>827597 I don't have a ton of experience with like less popular conlangs, the two ones I've really messed around with are lojban and toki pona. toki pona is really elegant, and the creator of that language did like a really good job of creating something minimal that's incredibly easy to learn. Of course though because of the limited vocabulary there's a ridiculous amount of ambiguity and it's really hard to communicate anything. lojban feels much clunkier, the grammar isn't quite as clean and it feels like there's parts of it that are tacked on, but the vocabulary is big enough and the grammar is expressive enough to communicate pretty effectively. It really feels like there should be some way to simplify lojban + make it more elegant, some base grammatical rules that you can derive everything else from.
Anno
>>827599 Oh do you have to manually break lines on this board
yeah
since the liveposting mechanic works by the last two words in the line, manual breaking is implemented so it doesn't immediately break the line and submit the quote live
just press enter
alt+s works to close your post instead of clicking done, as well
Anno
thanks!

I haven't been on any other live boards yet :)
Anno
>>827599
>>827600
The grammar can be expressed in computer code, so that seems elegant enough to me.
Anyway, most of the logic nerds are learning Toaq instead of Lojban these days.
Anno
Search [iqdb] (1 KB, 76x132, dako_sigil.png)
Anno
>>827709

lojban is barely parseable, there's got to be a way to make something simpler. I really should check out Toaq, it looks interesting but I'm not a huge fan of tones
FormerRei@mobile
>>827599
Toki pona is terrible. It feels like a language to limit the intelligence of its speakers. Like newspeak from 1984.
*language designed to limit
Anno
>>827984
Shut the fuck up, you non-lurking shit.
Research before you express your ignorance.
FormerRei@mobile
Oh so I was wrong about it having a limited vocabulary?
And a very limited set of words for numbers?
And one word for everything below the waist?
FormerRei@mobile
I might be wrong about that last one, heard it second hand from my friend who complains about Toki pona.
*I heard it second
FormerRei@mobile
>one two and many
Yeah sure its a great example of minimalism in language. But can you imagine being a person who only knew Toki pona?
It's terrifying, you would be so limited in your ability to express things.
So yeah, I did you a favlr and refreshed myself on it and I found that I was in fact correct.
*favor
Samu /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
build a language that fits neatly into tensors
FormerRei@mobile
Strings are one dimensional arrays of characters and one dimensional arrays are vectors. So it would be weirder for a language to not fit neatly into tensors.
Anno
Build a language that fits neatly in to ten sores
Samu /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
yeah but something that natively works
for strings you gotta process and do word2vec and shit and deal with all the deduping and BS of english
and then interpret the sequence or whatev
make a language with a series of idea vectors or something
FormerRei@mobile
Mite b cool
Anno
>>827993 >>827996
Explain.
Anno
if your language doesn't directly map to prolog then what's the point
Anno
>>828316
Prolog suxxx, lol.
so do you have a purpose in mind for this language
what prompted you to seek out collaborators and want to create a language? what's it going to be used for?
a technical or conceptual language to be used in the real world? a fictional language for worldbuilding in a fictional setting you've created?

i'm assuming it's just a general desire to explore the process itself, but assigning a purpose is going to be a good starting point
im a fan of minimalism personally so i can resonate with some of those sentiments expressed earlier
Anno
>>828391
I would like a "stealth"/secret language but without being a code or relexification.
What would you all like as the purpose?
that sounds interesting and doable
Anno
>>828412
A request: do not start wtih the phonology. It always causes arguments. And anyway, it can be fine-tuned later.
Anno
What types of sentences are there other than predicates and exclamations?

Those seem like a good starting point grammar-wise
Anno
>>828916
What else is there?
Anno
>>828973

good question lol
Samu /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
make a statement.
ask a question?
exclaim!
... fragment ...
if you have a condition, you can make a conditional statement
clause and clause
broke meme jalopy sentenc
Anno
>>828987
Aren't most of those just predicates?
Anno
Yeah I think most of those are predicates

Hmm, but I'm not really sure where to start, it seems like all the parts of a language
are entertwined.
Samu /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
if everything's a predicate then the utility of the concept of predicates is kinda low
Anno
>>829261
True, all things everywhere are interconnected but not all connected in the same way.
Samu /人◕ ‿‿ ◕人\
gotta start somewhere and can't get it perfect on the first pass
Anno
>>829792
So where do you want to start?

Return